Should You Upgrade Your Pool or Remove It? Here Are a Few Deciding Factors

Making the decision to keep your pool or replace it with something else can feel overwhelming. Pools are a big investment and require ongoing maintenance, making the process more complicated than simply scheduling a contractor and getting it done – there are a lot of decisions you need to make before jumping in (no pun intended).

In this article, we’ll dive into some of the important deciding factors that you should consider when it comes to keeping your pool or removing it altogether.

From energy costs to safety protocols, we have all bases covered so read on if you’re looking for advice on whether or not an upgrade is necessary!

Upgrade Your Pool 2

Consider the Cost of Pool Upgrades Versus the Cost of Pool Removal

One of the most crucial factors to consider is the cost comparison between a pool upgrade and a complete removal. Upgrading your pool might include installing energy-efficient equipment, redesigning the pool for better aesthetics, or adding features like heating systems, waterfalls, or lighting.

These enhancements can significantly increase your pool’s functionality and visual appeal, but they come with a price. On the other hand, the cost of pool removal involves draining, demolishing, and filling the pool area, followed by landscaping. It’s important to get estimates for both scenarios and consider your budget and long-term financial impact.

After all, while upgrades can enhance your property’s value, they also entail ongoing maintenance costs.

Evaluate the Usage of Your Pool 

When considering whether to have a pool or upgrade an existing one, it’s important to assess how frequently it is used by you, your family, or guests.

Take into account the joy and satisfaction it brings. If the pool is regularly and enthusiastically used, an upgrade might be a worthwhile investment, enhancing the overall experience.

However, if the pool remains unused for the majority of the year, it’s worth considering whether the cost of upkeep outweighs its benefits. In such cases, removal might be a more pragmatic option.

Consider the Climate in Your Area

The local climate is another crucial factor to consider when making a decision about your pool. For those fortunate enough to reside in warm climates where the pool can be enjoyed year-round, upgrading it could provide excellent value for money.

On the other hand, if you live in an area with limited pool usage due to weather constraints, such as colder temperatures or shorter summers, it might be more cost-effective to contemplate pool removal.

By considering the climate, you can make a decision that aligns with both your lifestyle and budget.

Assess the Impact on Property Value

The potential impact on your property value is an important aspect to examine. In certain real estate markets, having a pool can significantly enhance a home’s price and overall appeal, attracting potential buyers seeking this desirable feature.

However, in other markets, a pool might be viewed as an additional expense and responsibility, deterring prospective buyers who prefer to avoid the costs and efforts of pool maintenance.

To gauge the impact on property value, it’s advisable to research your local real estate market or consult with a trusted real estate professional.

This knowledge will assist you in making a decision that aligns with your long-term financial goals.

Reflect on Lifestyle and Future Plans

Take a moment to reflect on your current lifestyle and future plans when considering whether to upgrade or remove your pool. If you have young children who love to swim or frequently host pool parties, upgrading the pool might be a justifiable decision, enhancing the enjoyment and entertainment value for your family and guests.

However, if you have plans to retire or travel frequently, the pool could become an additional responsibility that you may prefer to avoid.

By carefully considering your future plans and lifestyle, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your long-term goals, convenience, and overall well-being.

Analyze Ongoing Maintenance Efforts

Maintaining a pool requires consistent effort, time, and financial resources. If you are already finding it challenging to keep up with the maintenance demands of your pool or if the costs are higher than anticipated, it might be worth considering the practicality of removing the pool altogether.

On the other hand, if you are willing to invest in an upgrade, it’s essential to recognize that this may result in additional maintenance requirements in the future.

Therefore, it’s crucial to evaluate your readiness for this increased commitment and ensure that you have the resources to sustain it.
Ultimately, the decision to upgrade or remove your pool depends on a myriad of factors, ranging from financial considerations and usage patterns to climate, property value implications, lifestyle, and ongoing maintenance.

Each aspect holds significant weight and must be evaluated in the context of your personal needs, desires, and long-term plans.

Remember, while a pool can offer unique enjoyment opportunities, it also comes with responsibility and costs. It’s crucial to make an informed decision that balances enjoyment with practicality.

By carefully considering all these factors, you can be confident in your decision, whether that is to upgrade your pool and enjoy its enhanced features, or eliminate the upkeep by removing it.

Ultimately, the choice should contribute positively to the quality of your life and align with your financial and personal goals.

Julie Higgins
Julie is a Staff Writer at She has been working in publishing houses before joining the editorial team at momooze. Julie's love and passion are topics around beauty, lifestyle, hair and nails.